The US government’s efforts to open up the notoriously murky
oil sector to public scrutiny were undermined today by Exxon and Chevron’s
failure to agree to declare their tax payments in the US, as required by a
landmark global transparency initiative that the US has recently joined.
Yesterday the US released its first report as a member of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) (1) , a global standard which aims to put information about government revenues from deals struck with oil and mining companies into the public domain in 49 countries across the world. This includes the taxes the companies pay, information which is key to ensuring people know what benefits they get from deals for their natural resources, and that decisions over such operations are made in their interest.
It is therefore deeply disappointing for US citizens that major companies like ExxonMobil and Chevron have opted not to disclose their tax contribution in the US. Other companies like Royal Dutch Shell and BP have shown that transparency is feasible and part of good corporate governance by reporting their tax payments.
“You have to ask what Exxon and Chevron have to hide from the US public,” said Zorka Milin, Senior Legal Advisor at Global Witness. “Citizens can now see that BP has contributed US$85 million in US federal corporate taxes during 2013, and decide if they think they are getting a fair deal for their resources. So why have ExxonMobil and Chevron refused to do the same?”
The news comes as the global push for greater transparency in the oil sector gathers momentum, with the US again lagging behind. Laws have recently been passed in the UK and EU to make companies like Shell and BP disclose the payments they make to foreign governments for access to natural resources. But a matching US law, known as Section 1504 of the Dodd-Frank Act, has been long delayed due to vehement opposition from the oil industry group American Petroleum Institute, in which ExxonMobil and Chevron are members.
More than five years after this law was enacted, it is now finally on the verge of being implemented. The US regulator, Securities and Exchange Commission, is committed to proposing an implementing rule this month and finalizing it next year.
Meanwhile, US companies have recently come under fire at EITI international board meetings over their unwillingness to report their taxes, which is a basic requirement of the scheme. This is particularly concerning, given that these companies are long standing supporters of the EITI and members of the international board. At the same time, the EITI board is trying to weaken the checks on how well countries adhere to its transparency requirements – a process known as validation - which is supported by the extractive companies on the board.
“The tide is turning towards transparency - it’s time the big US oil majors stopped paying lip service in public while doing all they can to preserve their secrecy behind closed doors,” said Milin. “US citizens deserve to know how much money they are putting in state coffers, as do citizens in resource rich countries throughout the world.”
Zorka MilinSenior Advisor, Fossil Gas
You might also like
Oil, gas and mining transparencyCorruption and fraud in the oil, gas and mining industries props up brutal regimes and lines the pockets of kleptocrats. Companies and governments must end the secrecy and bring deals and profits into the open
Statoil’s historic disclosures blow holes in Exxon and Shell’s campaign for secrecy简体中文 Transparency campaigners call on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to follow Norway’s lead
Shell and Eni's Misadventures in NigeriaIn 2011, Shell and Eni paid US$1.1bn for one of West Africa’s largest oil fields, situated off the coast of Nigeria, but the money did not benefit the country’s citizens.