Global Witness welcomes the LME’s recognition of the need for responsible sourcing but warns that proposals outlined in its October 2018 Position Paper will be ineffective in their current form.
Campaign Leader Sophia Pickles said:
“Used by some of the world’s largest metal producers and traders, and trading metal brands from over 60 countries worldwide, the LME has the power to change business behaviour where responsible metal trading is concerned - and not before time.”
“The LME claims it seeks consistency with the internationally recognised OECD Guidance but the measures laid out in this proposal fail to meet that standard on multiple fronts. Crucially, all companies, no matter what they source or from where, must report publicly on their supply chain due diligence efforts annually in order to meet OECD recommendations and provide proper assurances to the market. In its current iteration, the LME proposal fails to clearly require all producers of its listed brands to do this consistently and publicly.”
“Requiring companies to simply join an industry scheme or undergo an audit is inadequate. An OECD study released in April 2018 supported by Global Witness found significant weaknesses in audit practises and made clear that even where industry schemes are OECD-aligned, there is no guarantee that member companies are undertaking adequate supply chain checks. Industry schemes and audits are not a substitute for public reporting: a company must know and show its individual efforts to source minerals fairly and without contributing to harms.”
“As currently laid out, the LME suggestion to undertake additional due diligence on discounted cobalt brands risks creating serious unintended consequences and should be re-thought. This is a blunt mechanism that risks penalising artisanal supply and overlooking serious red flags in non-discounted metal supply chains. Increased due diligence should be triggered by evidence-led scrutiny and not by price alone.”
Global Witness will issue detailed comment on the LME Position Paper.
Sophia Pickles, Campaign Leader and Supply Chain Investigator
+44 (0) 7703 108 449
Notes to editor:
Sophia Pickles is speaking at LME Metals Week on Monday 8 October and is available for comment on +44 7703 108 449
You might also like
Conflict Minerals in Europe
After years of campaigning by Global Witness and civil society partners the EU has reached a political understanding on a new law intended to break the links between the minerals trade, conflict and human rights abuses.
Oil, Gas & Mining, Responsible MineralsPress release
The Cobalt Industry Risk Assessment Framework: A joint statement
Global Witness and seven other non-governmental organisations have written to the Cobalt Institute regarding their proposed Cobalt Industry Risk Assessment Framework.
Responsible MineralsBriefing Document
The Dodd Frank Act's Section 1502 on conflict minerals
For over a decade, the trade in conflict minerals has fueled human rights abuses and promoted insecurity in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). The Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, passed by the US Congress in July 2010, includes a provision – section 1502 – aimed at stopping the national army and rebel groups in the DRC from illegally using profits from the minerals trade to fund their fight.