Global Witness - Breaking the links between natural resources, conflict and corruption
Incoming Ukrainian President must act to clean up country’s gas industry
Press Release – 05/02/2010
The winner of this Sunday's runoff vote for the Ukrainian presidency between Yulia Tymoshenko and Viktor Yanukovych must take immediate steps to clean up Ukraine's notoriously mismanaged gas sector, said Global Witness today.
The poor governance of Ukraine's state gas company (Naftohaz Ukrainy) and use of shadowy intermediaries contributed to a dispute with Russia over gas prices and debts which in turn led to cuts in supplies to some European countries in 2006, and again in 2009, raising deep concerns about the security of European energy supplies from the former Soviet Union.
"Whoever wins the Ukraine election must launch a wide-ranging clean up of the gas sector," said Tom Mayne of Global Witness. "Ukraine's citizens have a right to know exactly how this vital sector is being managed and where its profits are going. Many people in the EU are rightly nervous that more governance problems could lead to yet more energy supply cuts in future."
The next president should make good on Ukraine's pledge to join the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, an international association with more than 30 member countries, and launch wider reforms to open up the Ukrainian energy sector to full public scrutiny.
The Orange Revolution of 2004 brought thousands of protesters on the street, calling for a more open and accountable system of governance in Ukraine, whose economy depends heavily on gas. Although Ukraine signed an agreement with the EU in March 2009 to reform its gas sector, progress has been slow, and the industry is little more transparent than it was before the revolution.
The history of Naftohaz Ukrainy is one of opacity and bad governance. As Global Witness documented in its 2006 report, It's a Gas, the company has been plagued by allegations of mismanagement and shadowy dealings. Most controversially, it used a mysterious private Swiss company, RosUkrEnergo (RUE), to arrange gas deliveries which the state company could have done itself.
RUE made a profit of more than US$2 billion in four years, yet neither Russia nor Ukraine ever clearly explained why this private company was needed. RUE was finally removed from the gas trade in early 2009 after yet another gas dispute between the two countries. Though the removal of RUE has been a positive step towards transparency, Ukrainian citizens are still unable to get full and timely information regarding Naftohaz Ukrainy. For example, the company has not published its accounts to international standards for 2004, 2006 and 2008.
"Naftohaz's massive debts led in part to the two Russian gas cut-offs. Therefore it is vital for the new president to conduct a comprehensive audit on the company, not only for 2008, but for all years retrospectively back to 2001," said Mayne.
Ukraine agreed to implement the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) in September 2009. This voluntary initiative, launched in the UK in 2002, requires signatory governments to publish the amounts of revenues they receive for exports of oil and gas, or, in Ukraine's case, the transit revenues. Global Witness welcomes Ukrainian accession to the EITI, but believes the country needs to go further. Ukraine should also ensure full transparency over the ownership of gas companies working in the country.
/ Ends
Contact: Amy Barry on +44 (0)7980 664397, +44 (0)207 4925858 or Tom Mayne on +44(0)20 7492 5864
Downloads
Latest Publications
March 2010
New evidence confirms oil revenue transparency still eludes Sudan
Large discrepancies persist between the oil production data published by the government of Sudan and those published by the main Chinese oil company operating in the country, Global Witness said today, six months after the publication of its report which first exposed the gaps.
Environmental groups call on French shipping company Delmas to cancel shipment of precious wood from Madagascar
Global Witness and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) today called on French shipping company Delmas to cancel a shipment to China of hundreds of tons of rosewood from the port of Vohémar, in northeastern Madagascar. The campaign groups accuse the company of facilitating the destruction of Madagascar’s last remaining forests caused by vast illegal logging of rosewood.
Open letter to Delmas shipping company raises concerns over rosewood shipments from Madagascar
An open letter from Global Witness and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) to Delmas shipping company expressing grave concerns at its involvement in the transport of timber from Madagascar which has been declared illicit by the Malagasy authorities. The groups accuse Delmas of facilitaitng the destruction Madagascar's remaining rosewood forests through illegal logging.
Link between Angolan president's son-in-law and state oil company raises questions about transparency
The son-in-law of the Angolan president has been nominated to the board of a holding company that owns a third of the Portuguese oil firm Galp Energia, which has investments in Angola. The nomination was made by the State oil company, Sonangol, which is responsible for managing Angola's oil on behalf of its citizens. This arrangement raises concerns about conflicts of interest to which Sonangol has not responded.
DR Congo: ex-rebels take over mineral trade extortion racket
Former rebels from the Congrès national pour la défense du peuple (CNDP) have established mafia-style extortion rackets covering some of the most lucrative tin and tantalum mining areas in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Global Witness reported today following four weeks of research in the region.
Global Witness concerned at choice of new Ukraine energy minister
Global Witness is concerned that Yuri Boyko, a controversial figure from the murky past of Ukraine’s gas industry, has been put back in effective charge of a key gas supply route from Russia to the European Union.
Landmark oil and mining transparency initiative faces credibility test as key deadline passes
The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), a pioneering initiative to bring more openness to the world's oil and mining industries, faces a major credibility test after 20 out of 22 countries failed to meet a key deadline today.
Global Witness urges Cambodia’s donors to condemn sponsorship of military units by private businesses
Aid donors to Cambodia, including the US, EU, Japan, China and the World Bank, should send a strong message to the government that they will not countenance the bankrolling of Cambodia’s military by private businesses. This call follows the announcement last week by Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen of the formation of 42 official partnerships between private businesses and Cambodian military units.
February 2010
A near miss? Lessons learnt from the allocation of mining licences in the Gola Forest Reserve in Sierra Leone
Between 2005 and 2007, two mining licences were issued in the Gola Forest Reserve in Sierra Leone, even though the area was a proposed national park. This new report identifies weaknesses in Sierra Leone's natural resource governance and attempts to draw lessons for the future.
Parliamentary committee report on libel, privacy and press freedom not strong enough to defend public interest reporting
A report on press standards, privacy and libel makes broadly sensible recommendations but does not go far enough to allay fears that England's laws are a barrier to public-interest campaigning.
Campaigners criticise proposals to define palm oil plantations as forests
The Ecosystems Climate Alliance today criticised the EU and Indonesia for attempting to reclassify palm oil plantations as forests, saying this would be a step backwards in efforts to halt climate change though preventing deforestation.
