Global Witness - Breaking the links between natural resources, conflict and corruption
As the dust settles, some cause for optimism…
Blog – 21/12/2009
Blog from Patrick Alley, Director of Global Witness
The fall out from the debacle that was Copenhagen will take some time to settle, but there is a glimmer of hope to be seen amidst the toxic debris: REDD is not dead! In fact the negotiating text on Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation is more advanced than most other areas of the climate change negotiations, and Global Witness and our colleagues in the Ecosystems Climate Alliance can see a lot of the language we wrote represented in the latest drafts. This is a testament to the relationships we've built with key negotiators, who now ask for our inputs on specific text and on the broader forest context.
Of course, the negotiations didn't reach an agreement on REDD, because they didn't reach a legally binding agreement on anything, but the Copenhagen Accord does acknowledge the importance of REDD, and specifies that it will benefit from a share of the $30 billion that developed countries have committed for climate change mitigation between 2010 - 2012. This is, of course, still a paltry amount when compared to the task in hand, and especially when compared to the gargantuan sums thrown at the global banking and automotive industries, but at least there is a commitment.
The latest REDD language still reflects the advances we made last week. These include recognition that forest dependent peoples are an essential part of the process, that safeguards are needed to protect natural forests against conversion to agriculture and plantations, and that monitoring is important (though this is still the subject of debate). The pro-logging lobby failed in its behind the scenes lobbying attempts to include the term ‘sustainable forest management' (SFM) in a future REDD agreement. Sustainable Forest Management is effectively double-speak for industrial scale logging. It seems arcane, but the phrasing in the current text - ‘sustainable management of forests' - does not ‘lock in' the logging sector as the other term would. These negotiations are all about legal language and such distinctions are critical.
On the down side, there are still no targets for overall reduction of deforestation or degradation. An earlier version of the text had a target of 50% reduction of deforestation by 2020 but this was removed. And of course, the text is still unfinished. But this is a double-edged sword: the talks will now continue throughout 2010 with the hope of a final agreement at Mexico in November or December. This gives us more time to try and fine tune the language and hopefully to prevent any retraction of the progress we've made thus far.
On a broader note, it was fascinating, if not disturbing, to see the biggest and most important international negotiations of our age collapse into acrimony, logistical chaos and macro-political manoeuvring. Personally I think we are witnessing the seismic shifting of the tectonic plates of the political order, as the emerging economies of Brazil, India and China flex their new and growing political and economic muscles. Political fault lines lead to political earthquakes, and Copenhagen just suffered the first big one.
Read previous blog
Return to Copenhagen main page
Latest Publications
March 2010
New evidence confirms oil revenue transparency still eludes Sudan
Large discrepancies persist between the oil production data published by the government of Sudan and those published by the main Chinese oil company operating in the country, Global Witness said today, six months after the publication of its report which first exposed the gaps.
Environmental groups call on French shipping company Delmas to cancel shipment of precious wood from Madagascar
Global Witness and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) today called on French shipping company Delmas to cancel a shipment to China of hundreds of tons of rosewood from the port of Vohémar, in northeastern Madagascar. The campaign groups accuse the company of facilitating the destruction of Madagascar’s last remaining forests caused by vast illegal logging of rosewood.
Open letter to Delmas shipping company raises concerns over rosewood shipments from Madagascar
An open letter from Global Witness and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) to Delmas shipping company expressing grave concerns at its involvement in the transport of timber from Madagascar which has been declared illicit by the Malagasy authorities. The groups accuse Delmas of facilitaitng the destruction Madagascar's remaining rosewood forests through illegal logging.
Link between Angolan president's son-in-law and state oil company raises questions about transparency
The son-in-law of the Angolan president has been nominated to the board of a holding company that owns a third of the Portuguese oil firm Galp Energia, which has investments in Angola. The nomination was made by the State oil company, Sonangol, which is responsible for managing Angola's oil on behalf of its citizens. This arrangement raises concerns about conflicts of interest to which Sonangol has not responded.
DR Congo: ex-rebels take over mineral trade extortion racket
Former rebels from the Congrès national pour la défense du peuple (CNDP) have established mafia-style extortion rackets covering some of the most lucrative tin and tantalum mining areas in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Global Witness reported today following four weeks of research in the region.
Global Witness concerned at choice of new Ukraine energy minister
Global Witness is concerned that Yuri Boyko, a controversial figure from the murky past of Ukraine’s gas industry, has been put back in effective charge of a key gas supply route from Russia to the European Union.
Landmark oil and mining transparency initiative faces credibility test as key deadline passes
The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), a pioneering initiative to bring more openness to the world's oil and mining industries, faces a major credibility test after 20 out of 22 countries failed to meet a key deadline today.
Global Witness urges Cambodia’s donors to condemn sponsorship of military units by private businesses
Aid donors to Cambodia, including the US, EU, Japan, China and the World Bank, should send a strong message to the government that they will not countenance the bankrolling of Cambodia’s military by private businesses. This call follows the announcement last week by Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen of the formation of 42 official partnerships between private businesses and Cambodian military units.
February 2010
A near miss? Lessons learnt from the allocation of mining licences in the Gola Forest Reserve in Sierra Leone
Between 2005 and 2007, two mining licences were issued in the Gola Forest Reserve in Sierra Leone, even though the area was a proposed national park. This new report identifies weaknesses in Sierra Leone's natural resource governance and attempts to draw lessons for the future.
Parliamentary committee report on libel, privacy and press freedom not strong enough to defend public interest reporting
A report on press standards, privacy and libel makes broadly sensible recommendations but does not go far enough to allay fears that England's laws are a barrier to public-interest campaigning.
Campaigners criticise proposals to define palm oil plantations as forests
The Ecosystems Climate Alliance today criticised the EU and Indonesia for attempting to reclassify palm oil plantations as forests, saying this would be a step backwards in efforts to halt climate change though preventing deforestation.
